Donor Sperm: The Sequel

Grace Hebert - Donor Sperm - jGirls+ Magazine

I have always known the truth about being conceived from donor sperm. The idea of knowing my half-brothers and -sisters had always wandered around in the back of my imagination. It seemed unrealistic, like it would happen in a far-away universe. I daydreamed about walking down a New York City street on a brisk fall day, a scarf wrapped around my neck, and passing a face similar to mine. I imagined somehow knowing that I shared half the DNA behind that face. I thought about the happily-ever-after connection between the two of us. Meeting my siblings never seemed like a plausible reality.

Out of all the men who apply to be a sperm donor, only 5-10% qualify. There are 14 major sperm banks in the United States, and the application process is extensive for all of them. Donors must be free of STIs and HIV and under the age of 40. Prospective donors must provide three generations’ worth of family medical history, and some banks require genetic testing. If men make it past the rigorous application and into the sperm donation program, they are required to make donations once a week for about a year. Sperm donors only get paid when their sperm count meets a certain threshold, so they have to watch their alcohol intake, how much sleep they get, and what food they put into their bodies. Because of this extensive and selective process, who would want to do it? Most donors are college students looking for extra cash. A small percentage are men in their thirties, some with families, who feel like helping people. If they personally know someone with infertility, sperm donation may be way of giving back.

I heard about the Donor Sibling Registry (DSR) from a friend in the same predicament as me. Both of us had lesbian moms who used donor sperm in order to conceive. What intrigued me was that about a year before, my friend had managed to find and meet her half-siblings on the DSR, an online database and center for families who used donor sperm. The idea that I could find people out there half-related to me was mind-altering.

Later that afternoon, my mom and I sat parked on the spring-green rug in my room. I gazed at the computer screen before us, all set up to register on the site. Anticipation built inside me as waves of unrecognizable emotions wafted to the surface. I continued to stare blankly at the computer screen as my mom typed away. Last and first name. Sperm bank used. Donor number. Type of membership wanted on the Donor Sibling Registry. I reminded myself over and over to take the next breath.

Throughout most of history, sperm donation has been shrouded in secrecy. When donor insemination first started, it was used only for heterosexual couples in which the male was infertile. Sperm donation was pushed into the shadows because male infertility was seen as a disgrace. As sperm donation became more widely used, doctors failed to keep adequate records that linked donors to recipients. While secrecy is no longer the norm, many sperm banks still fail to keep sufficient records. In an article published in Politics and the Life Sciences, Barbara Raboy speaks on the behalf of the Sperm Bank of California, saying, “When we opened in 1982, some of our clients asked us to develop a way for donors to be identified by the offspring. At the time, this idea was unheard of and was not offered by any sperm bank or physician in the United States.” In 1983, the Sperm Bank of California established its donor identity-release policy. This allowed donors to choose if they wanted to be identified when their offspring reached the age of 18.

Later that night, less than 24 hours after e-mailing the list of names that came up under donor #448 of the Pacific Reproductive Services, two alerts popped into my mom’s inbox. Two e-mails that, at the same time, managed to both glare and beam at us — messages from two of my half-siblings.

What was I supposed to say to these people I knew as little about as college calculus, but who shared half of my genetic code? I was in seventh grade at the time, and I remember getting launched into talking with my sister Gracie. We exchanged questions like “What do you do in your free time?” and “What’s your favorite color?” Pastimes and favorite colors were trivial, but neither of us knew how to interact. We were like two dogs, tentatively sniffing at each other’s territories. Just like any two dogs at first, we had yet to know if our cautions would evaporate and our odors would mix.

Back when donor insemination first started, the term “sperm donor” was nonexistent. If a doctor was helping an infertile heterosexual couple become pregnant, the doctor would ask a healthy medical student to quietly donate. It was out of the question for the couple to request sperm from a specific person. Between the first use of donor insemination in 1790 and the start of freezing sperm in 1953, the practice was kept hush-hush. As sperm freezing evolved throughout the 1950’s and 60’s, the sperm bank industry expanded, especially in the United States. The clientele dominating the sperm consumer market shifted from heterosexual couples to single women and lesbians, and the issue of choice shifted as well.

Some argue that having the right to choose a donor means that the child will be less valued if he or she is not born with the characteristic desired by the parents. A strong moral principle in our society is that parents should accept their children the way they are. “Some commercial sperm banks, in their advertising, emphasize the idea that choosing the donor equals choosing the characteristics of the future child,” said an article In the Oxford Journal Human Reproduction. What the child will look like can only be guessed at and not known for certain. On the other side, people argue for the right to choose a donor because it gives the woman or couple more control over the process. The article in Human Reproduction continued, “A person should have the right to make his/her own decisions. Choosing one’s donor, like choosing one’s partner, can be considered as one of those decisions.”

As I began to find more and more of my siblings, my heart grew to include these people. I scoured their Instagrams and stared at their pictures. None of them looked like replicas of me or of each other, but here and there I found that we shared the same eyes or the same cheekbones.

Maybe a month after joining the DSR, a new question arose between my moms and me. How many people had successfully conceived with donor #448’s sperm? How many half-siblings were there? One mom kept a running list of every #448 family that had contacted her, but that’s all we had. Parents are not required to report a birth using donor sperm, so there is no accurate count of how many children have been conceived from mine or anyone else’s donor. Another mom in the #448 gang told us she had heard from the sperm bank that there were anywhere from 30-50 of us. Even if that wasn’t true, and facts had somehow become scrambled up, I had feelings I couldn’t identify. Maybe bewilderment, maybe wonder, maybe even terror.

In the movie Delivery Man, a guy discovers that, after donating sperm in his 20’s, he now has 533 offspring. Men with a very high sperm count who donate every week for a year could contribute to 30 pregnancies in that year. It would take decades for them to have 500 children. So while this is extremely unlikely, there have been reported cases of donors having 100 or more offspring. According to Wendy Kramer, founder of the Donor Sibling Registry, there are multiple groups containing between 150-200 siblings.

Even if banks set a limit on how many families are allowed to conceive using a donor’s sperm, they depend on families reporting successful births to the bank, which does not always happen. National regulations focus much more on the quality of the sperm rather than how much is donated. Officials report an estimated 30,000-60,000 births that come from donated sperm each year.

One of the #448 moms, we found out, was organizing a meetup. Right around the time we first joined the DSR, she happened to be in the midst of planning it. “Do you want to go?” my mom asked. Of course I wanted to go and meet these people. Of course I wanted to talk to and get to know them.

To date, more than 13,102 half-siblings have found each other through the DSR. In an online research study, donor conceived children were asked about their reasons for searching for donor siblings. The two main responses were: “curiousity about appearance and personality” and “to know and understand a missing part of me.” The study showed that donor offspring made connections with their siblings that were generally positive. Most of the offspring who chose to search for their siblings were open about it with parents, friends, and family. When I searched for my siblings, I did not feel self-conscious or embarrassed. I felt joyous that I had found them, and I wanted to share that joy.

We decided to gather in Boston, with a couple families living there, a couple families driving up, and a couple families driving down. The car ride was long, sweaty, and filled with anticipation. My moms read aloud to each other while I listened to music, staring out of the window and letting my mind wander from absolutely nothing, to the meetup, and then back to absolutely nothing. After parking the car and hauling our belongings inside a friend’s house, there was not much time to get ready before having to go join everyone. I was stuck. It was the end of summer and 80 degrees outside. Should I wear short-shorts? Should I put makeup on? What were the other girls going to wear? “We need to go in five minutes,” one of my moms yelled. I hastily pulled myself together, jammed flip-flops on my feet, grabbed my phone, and hurtled down the stairs.

As I settled into the sweaty back seat, I noticed directions, printed on a piece of scrap paper, lying on my mom’s lap. I was immediately mistrustful, from countless times of similar scribbled directions leading us into hours of being lost. About halfway through the drive, we became, as I predicted, utterly lost. I am not a person who can tolerate being late, so with 10 minutes to get there, a nervous sheen of sweat broke out on my skin, and my heartbeat rose.

Twenty minutes later, after getting different directions, the actual right address, and a helpful phone call from one the #448 parents, we pulled into the gravel driveway, a big wrap-around porch staring at us ominously. We were all hesitant to open the car doors, until a friendly looking woman came galloping out and introduced herself as Kathy. “It’s so nice to meet you, I’m so glad you finally made it. Come on inside, everyone is already here,” she said.

The parents were scattered in small clusters around the house, but all of the half-siblings were seated in the living room. The feeling I had walking into that small, yet immense, gathering of people was like walking into the cafeteria on the first day of school. Meeting them one at a time was hard enough, but since I was the last one there, I was faced with six half-siblings all staring at me. It took me a moment to realize that they were smiling and welcoming me in, introducing themselves, and making room for me on the couch. Their faces were a blur. Manners held me back from staring at them, but I jumped on every chance I had to sneak in glances.

I don’t remember what we all talked about gathered in that living room– maybe what activities we enjoyed, maybe what we were going to be doing later. There was a surreal feeling to that living room. It came from the doorway, the cerulean wall paint, the two plush chairs, and the one large couch. It came from the nervous tapping of one’s shoes on the floor, and the thick buzz of the ceiling fan. It came from the teeth peeking out from under our smiles and the polite laughter chirping from our throats. Thankfully, it wasn’t long before the parents decided it was time to start the evening. Piling into various cars, we made our way over to a picnic below a sky of fireworks.

The families sprawled over numerous blankets, relaxing and chatting with one another as the last few finished up their meals. We waited with restless patience as shades of deep blue and red swirled into the sky. I don’t know which sibling was first to document the time on Snapchat, but soon we found a bit of the wall dividing us crumble as we exchanged usernames, gathering friends and followers. I sank into the toasty air, feeling comforted by the glowing eyes around me, and watched the fireworks explode into shards of flame.

Later that night, we stopped at a massive ice cream parlor filled with chatter and life. Again, looking at the menu, I was faced with an array of choices. What was I supposed to order? I didn’t want to order a double sundae and look greedy. I didn’t want to order vanilla in a dish and look boring. I didn’t want to order some made-up flavor decked with candy and nuts and look weird.

Eventually, settling down into our various orders, we began to laugh. Most of us were Jewish, only children with lesbian parents. We understood each other’s families; we got each other’s jokes. Even though we had completely typical school lives, none of us had lives at home that matched the ones of our friends with “normal” families. We were all connected by this choice our parents had made. A selection between this vial of sperm or that one.

Our laughter didn’t quit until the parents starting saying, “It’s late, and we should call it a night.” Even then, we lingered outside the ice cream parlor, bringing our laughter with us, feeling lucky to have each other. I was no longer trying to impress them, no longer worried about what I looked like or what I said. I was allowed to effortlessly be myself.

I assume one day I’ll meet my donor dad. It, too, seems like a remote scenario playing out in the back corner of my brain. There was once a time when I yearned to have a dad. I felt like there was a hole needing to be filled. Meeting my siblings filled that hole in a way I didn’t expect. Overnight, I changed from being an only child to being part of a clan. I didn’t need a dad or any type of paternal figure. I had siblings.

Accompanying Photo: “Sperm Graffiti,” © Grace Hebert, licensed under Creative Commons 2.0.
What do you think about this topic? We want to hear from you!
Join the conversation!
Sasha Hochman is a high school senior in the International Baccalaureate program at Central High School in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. She is also a spin-class enthusiast who loves to think, philosophize, and read everything from The New York Times to the stack of novels by her bed. Her family belongs to a progressive Reconstructionist synagogue. She is a teaching fellow at Breakthrough, an organization that seeks to benefit Philadelphia’s under-resourced students by helping them to get to and through college. In her free time, she loves to listen to jazz, update herself on Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s life, and explore her city. Sasha has been a member of the jGirls+ Magazine editorial board since 2016-2017 and is the Poetry Department Head.